draft question: 'Human experiences are shaped by the tensions between personal desires and societal expectations.’
To what extent does your prescribed text explore the above statement? In your response, refer closely to at least two poems from the prescribed suite. (Gwen Harwood: Selected Poems)
Individual experiences are formed through collisions between our personal desires to act with agency and the societal expectations of conforming to collective/universal human experiences. Gwen Harwood explores these tensions in her poems ‘At Mornington’, ‘The Violets’ and ‘Beyond Metaphor’, touching on themes such as fluidity of time, persistence of memory, mortality, and psychological pain. These concepts involve conflicting struggles; whether to abide by reality and in turn, society’s expectations, or to follow one’s unreasonable dreams determinedly despite limitations.
Gwen Harwood contrasts a persona’s naïve aspirations of their childhood with the grounding reality of adulthood in her poem ‘At Mornington’ by utilising a range of literary devices to portray the above themes. Harwood employs a biblical allusion where she reflects on herself in her youth, “believing / As a child” that she could “walk on water”, directly comparing her to Jesus. It depicts the young girl’s irrational desire for power and control over matter, illustrating the innocence and hubris that accompany childhood fantasies. The girl is unable to absorb that reality is preventing her from achieving her impossible goal of walking over “The next wave, the next wave”. Later in life, as a grown woman, the narrator reflects on her childhood memories while considering the present moment as she and her friend “stand… / By your parents’ grave in silence”. Harwood juxtaposes the living figures of the two friends with the dead parents, symbolising the transient nature of life and how mortality is inevitable for all. Conversely, in the face of this adult awareness of death, the narrator’s prior beliefs in her endless vitality seem ridiculous. It emphasises the naivety of children and creates tensions between their personal desires and reality’s expectations of adhering to life’s rules. Additionally, it also creates friction between the child’s carefree lifestyle and the responsibilities of old age, when “our bones begin to wear us”. In this verse, a metaphor is used to compare aging to erosion or degradation, as the earth does over time. It demonstrates that while memories of a bygone time can be preserved, our physical bodies will continue to wither away. The persona, in her childhood, is not aware of this reality, and therefore holds the concept of ‘forever’ close to her, while the matured adult has accepted her fate and what will come for her in the future.
Harwood’s poem ‘The Violets’ exposes a child’s inability to comprehend the passing of time and general change, describing it with a variety of poetic techniques. Harwood writes, “‘Where’s morning gone?’”, using a rhetorical question to portray the girl’s despair. The audience is left with the tender emotional response of a young girl who doesn’t know that time comes and goes and cannot be retrieved once gone, evoking pity from the readers. The persona refuses the accept the loss of day, not allowing herself to “hold / The sweetness or to be comforted”. Harwood utilises enjambment to create a conversational tone, allowing the reader insight into the narrator’s thoughts. This verse further implicates the child’s incapability to understand sudden change, revealing her innocent and stubborn nature. Furthermore, time is personified in the following verse, “That while I slept, had stolen from me”. Time is given the human capacity to commit theft by stealing daylight from the persona. In addition to that, the girl isstill unable to “grasp or name” what exactly has taken away the hours of the day, further reinforcing her naivety. Her personal desire for morning to return clashes with the reality of the fluidity of time, influencing her to eventually give up and take her supper and get “sent / To innocent sleep”, free from her previous worries of the day; thus, conforming to societal expectations of allowing change to pass and impact oneself.