I remember, my grandmother used to call me doll, in her Southern accent, standing over me in those sun-soaked mornings at her house, when the light filtered through the pink cotton curtains and painted everything in rose, and the house smelt like cinnamon and oranges. I was sent there, after The Event, as I called it, nineteen with lanky legs and a chest too broad for my liking. She cut my hair, calling it a country hick mullet, and would not let me in the kitchen.
I do not believe she hated me.
She loved me, and she loved God, and the Devil was inside her, telling her it was inside me, wearing my father's old clothes, two sizes too big on my skinny frame. She called my glasses too feminine, and would not let me wear them, on my mother's orders. I called her on the landline the day I arrived, and then never again. It wasn't a pleasant conversation. When the sun rose, and she placed a home-cooked breakfast, bacon, eggs and grits, hashbrowns and a cup of coffee, all delicious, because it was Nana's cooking, and she still loved me, she told me she had applied for a job on my behalf.
I arrived at the lumber mill with the sun smearing my already failing retinas into bright puddles of light. The paper bag in my hand held a corned beef sandwich and an apple, a can of soda jostling around inside as if setting me up for certain embarrassment later in the day. A large man exited the mill, arms bursting with muscle, and he waved me over with all the authority of a cop. I trudged over.
"You the new hire?"
I nodded. "Name's El-"
"Elliot Hanson, I know 'ya. You Gertie's boy?"
I swallowed. "Grandson." The word slid past my lips like sandpaper.
"Well, I'm not sure what she was thinking. You ain't hauling shit with noodle arms like yours," he grasped my bicep suddenly, laughing all the while. "I'm Hank."
"Hi, Hank."
Hank sighed, and waved me inside. "Alright, son. I'll put you on some easy work for now. You'll be with Robin," he led me to a desk with a girl stood at it, bundling lumber into piles for shipment, and left me there.
"Hey, new blood. What's your name?" She asked, her strawberry blonde hair specked with sawdust. Her hands were calloused as they deftly wound a zip-tie around another bundle. It struck me suddenly that she may have been the prettiest girl I had ever seen.
I looked down as I said it, already fiddling with the plastic tail of a zip-tie. "Ella."
Robin chuckled lightly, and in that moment, since the event, all the soul I thought had drained out of me flew back to me.
"Ella, huh?"
"No, I-" I started, quietly tripping over my words. "El. El is fine."
Robin's eyes lingered a beat too long, long enough that I could feel sweat forming beneath the cotton of my two-sized too big shirt. "El, then." She flicked her chin at the pile beside her. "Grab that end."
I did as I was told. The lumber was rough under my palms, seams of bark still clinging in places, and the two of us hefted the plank onto the stack together. It wasn't heavy, not really, but my noodle arms strained anyway. Hank's words, already lodged somewhere behind my ribs, and as I was soon to learn, there would be many more words to come, sticking to much more painful places.
"You're stronger than you look," Robin said, and I couldn't tell if she meant it or if she was just being kind.
"Yeah, well. Been carrying suitcases my whole life," I said, and she laughed again, that same easy sound, like it cost her nothing.
We fell into a rhythm. She'd hand me the zip-ties, I'd feed them through, cinch them tight, and she'd stack. The sawdust hung gold in the light slanting through the high windows, and somewhere behind us a saw screamed through wood, and Hank's voice barked something at somebody else. It was loud, and hot, and my shirt, even with the collar gaping at my throat like a too-loose noose, stuck to my back within the hour.
"So," Robin said, not looking at me, focused on the next bundle. "Gertie's your grandma."
"Yeah."
"She's somethin'." Robin said it carefully, the way you'd test ice on a pond. "She come to church with my mama sometimes, Mavis Kennedy? Prays real loud."
I didn't answer that. I picked at the zip-tie tail instead, the plastic biting a thin red line into my thumb.
"You don't gotta talk about it," Robin said, softer now, and I felt her glance flick over to me and away, quick, like she was giving me room to breathe. "I just...you looked kinda far off, when Hank was talking. Like you were somewhere else."
"I was thinking about the corned beef sandwich in my bag," I lied, and she snorted.
"Liar."
"Yeah," I admitted. "Liar."
The whistle blew for break not long after, a shriek that cut through the saw-noise and sent men filing toward the shade of the loading dock. Robin wiped her hands on her jeans and jerked her head toward the door. "C'mon. You can eat that sad little sandwich next to me instead of alone."
I followed her out into the white heat of noon. She would later be the first person to give The Event a name. She called it dismemberment.
I had been working at that mill for over two weeks, gruelling work under the heat of summer, finally graduated from bundling lumber to cutting it. I felt guilty then, accepted into ranks of men, and abandoning Robin at her lone table, a strawberry-blonde beacon in a room of sweaty browns and greys. I came home ever day with the wail of the machinery in my head, saw hollering in my ears even as I pushed peas and potatoes around my china plate under Nana's gaze. She did not ask me much, outside of that polite small talk where she skated around any meaningful discussion. She asked about the mill, the machinery I'd learned to work, if any of the guys had invited me out.
I told her that they had not.
That much was true, but the guilt of the lie did not hit me until after dinner, one Wednesday night, when the wind was knocking at the windows, and she led me out to the front room. She grabbed me by my shoulders, and though it was tender, I had to shut my eyes to pretend it wasn't another arrestation. She pointed up, at a photo above the mantelpiece, I had seen every year in my childhood but never looked at. It was grandpa, who Nana called a good man, smiling his gap-tooth grin. In one hand he held his hunting rifle. The other, he rested on the stiffened, bristle-haired flank of a deer, rendered in black-and white. She sighed then, pulled back to look at me in my father's shirt, and said he would have taken you hunting, too. A man's rite of passage.
I invited Robin over that next evening, when Nana was out at her friend Barbara's. I had only once had a girl over before long before The Event, when I had stuffed my wooden-plank body into boxers and basketball shorts, and stuffed that body into the waiting pockets of blonde-haired mirror images, all the while hoping that sweat through osmosis would act like an alchemist's solution. I had not once withdrawn feeling satisfied, and I was certain that both Emma May and Jenny Walters had faked it for my benefit, wailing like cicadas in the night, with none of the shed skin to show for it.
Robin arrived at my doorstep in jeans and a flannel, shirt stained and hair pinned back by a thin, yellow Alice band. I had greeted her in my aunt's old jeans, and again, my father's too-big shirt, because I felt that I would be best not to overdo anything. I welcomed her in with a shaking hand, and fixed her a tall glass of sweet tea as she sat on my Nana's couch. The air smelt like oranges, and was stagnant as swamp water. She did not expect it, and that was the first shock. I had told her, in confidence of the heat blanketing us under the static TV spitting out evangelical nonsense and infomercials intermittently that she worked with so many guys, and no one had looked at her twice? She replied they think I'm bulldyke, and that was that. I did not ask are you, for fear of breaking the spell, the way she said it at speaking volume, as if it was not to be hidden, and for the first time in my short life, I wondered if the word could ever be spoken like that.
She asked again, if I wanted to talk about it. The Event hung above us both, marking this stranger with its searing intensity as it held me, and she waited, sweet tea sweating on the table in front of us. I told her honestly, and at that, she placed her lips onto mine. It was only an hour later when we lay across my Nana's couch that it hit me that, yes she was, and the answer was still clinging to my skin and hers. My eyes were blurry from joy and from my failing eyes, and I told her when she went to shower about the glasses atop the medicine cabinet, she returned minutes later, back in her torn flannel, pressing the arms against my ears, through my hair, and clarity overcame me.
She looked at me with her cheeks flushed the same shade as her hair, and I could almost count the freckles dotting her face, as she ran her fingers across my collarbone. I wanted to flinch at the action, but she flinched first, looking at the clock, saying that her mama would want her home. She did not ask about mine. She understood too, that dismemberment meant that both parts were severed, and would not meet again.
I learnt that Robin did not return home to a peaceful house that night in the morning. She had showed up in a leather jacket too thick for the sweaty air of the mill, sleeves pulled right up the way that Hank would've banned if she were working any of the machines. Get sucked right into that blade, you would, he'd say, pointing out another man on the production line with a missing finger as proof. I met her on lunch, and she held out an ice-cold can of soda to me, in a way that I could see her sleeve ride up. At the base of her hand, where her wrist began, sat a red ring, angry and glossy, like a cigarette burn.
She caught me staring immediately. "My Ma."
I felt my mouth dry up. "Your Ma?"
She shrugged. "Missed curfew."
"Robin, I'm so sorry, I-"
She held up a hand to silence me. "Not your fault. She would've found another excuse if it wasn't curfew." She shouldered off the jacket then, revealing her upper back, scarcely hidden by her spaghetti strap top. The pale flesh was marked by an intricate spider web of scars, some thick, some thin, all greying shades of pink, a massive constellation that I hadn't noticed when I had my hands all over her last night. "Go on," she said. "You can touch it."
I did, reaching my too-fat fingers out to run them across the lines, expecting to find raised lines like a manuscript of Braille, lash-marks, angry and throbbing. I only found smooth skin.
"Yeah, I scrub the hell out of it every night. Stops the scars from forming proper." Her voice was casual, so casual that it hurt something deep inside of me.
"Robin, I-"
"Ella," she said, and the two syllables felt foreign when addressed to me, so much that I blinked back at her before she extended a hand and motioned me to sit beside her. "El."
I sat, and she snorted. "Don't pretend you've got it any better."
"My folks might not...they don't...I don't have scars like that, Robin."
"Yeah, well, you ain't bulldyke," she said, and the word landed again, like a stone in my gut. "Or are you?" She turned to me with one eyebrow raised.
My stomach turned. "Robin--"
She smiled. "Only joking."
She got me into her car after work ended, both of us bundled into the front of her breaking down truck. She helped me climb onto the hood, citing my noodle arms as reason for such womanly chivalry, and finally made me smile at the words, which I appreciated more than anything. We pitched up at the creek on the edge of town, a small wooden footbridge laying in the distance, like something out of a kid's book. She kicked off her sneakers, shaking sawdust from them, and rolled up her jeans. For once, I didn't mind the mosquitoes biting at the thick meat of my calves, though I knew I would soon, when the wounds became rubbed raw and bloody, agitated by the sweat tracking through them under the heat of the mill tomorrow morning.
Then, she reached into her bag, and produced another set of squashed sandwiches, and a long log of cake.
"Ma made too much again," Robin said, by way of explanation. "She does that when she's feeling guilty."
She unwrapped the sandwiches, wax paper crinkling, and handed me the fatter of the two. I peeled back the bread to reveal ham and something orange that might've been cheese. I ate it anyway. It was better than my own soggy corned beef had been in weeks, going warm in its paper bag under the truck seat.
"You doing alright?" She asked.
I picked a piece of crust off instead of answering right away. The creek moved past below us, carrying a leaf that was too yellow for July, and somewhere further down the bank a bullfrog hummed its mating call.
"I keep waiting for something to go wrong," I admitted finally. "Been two weeks and nothing's gone wrong yet. Nana hasn't said anything. Hank hasn't said anything. You--You didn't make it weird. After last night. Most people would've made it weird."
Robin snorted, wiping a crumb off her chin with the back of her hand. "Nice of you to point it out." She broke off a piece of cake, then broke off a bigger piece and handed it over. "Besides. Waiting for the bad thing don't stop it coming. Just means you don't get to enjoy the sandwich while you got it." She grinned, sawdust still caught somewhere in the part of her hair, copper in the late light. "Y'know your problem, El?"
"I'm sure you'll tell me at some point." I lay back beside her, laying my head on her chest. "Just not today, okay?" The smiled softly in response, the metal of the hood ticking as it cooled, her shoulder warm against mine, and for twenty minutes she sat beside me, humming softly.
Then, after a long, sweet while, she pointed out at the water, and said: "Wanna go in?" and didn't wait for an answer.
Almost immediately, she was waist deep in the water, me wading in afterwards. She splashed me, and I smiled, splashing her back and receiving a much louder shriek. Laughing, she cussed me out, peeling the shirt from her torso in one swift motion. The sight of her then almost made me keel over, the flesh blooming where mine did not, and I stilled there in my t-shirt, soaked, and clinging to my wooden-plank shoulders. Her smile didn't drop.
She ran back to her car and held out a bikini top, pink and white striped, the kind of thing I assumed she wouldn't be caught dead wearing. She held it out in question.
"Why do you have that?" I asked.
She shrugged. "Emergency change of clothes. My car's a piece of junk, and the roads out here are long."
She tossed it to me anyways.
The first time the phone rang, I picked it up, while Nana was distracted in the kitchen door closed. I would have regretted this choice a lot more if the person on the other end of the line had been anyone other than Rosanna. I stood there, hair still wet, with the marks of Robin’s gift still impressed across my hips and chest. I could feel my hands getting sweatier as the handset started slipping through my fingers as her voice echoed down the line, quiet and small, and threaded with an unmistakable wobble as she tried to hold back her tears.
"El?"
I held my breath. "Hi, Rosie."
"When are you coming home? Dad said--"
"I'll be home by the time school starts, Ro." I didn’t know that was a lie yet, but I strongly suspected it would be, and I tried to keep my voice even as it came from my mouth.
"But that's not fair! I wanna spend summer with you!"
"I know," I said, rolling the fabric of my shirt collar between my sweating fingers.
"What did you do? They said you...um...messed up." Her words caught on her self imposed childish censorship, as if the crime of quoting her elders was anywhere near as bad as the transgression she had already committed by dialing Nana’s number. “How’s Nana?”
“She’s good. She’s gardening.”
“Isn’t it dark out?” Rosanna asked, and I could almost see her, head tilted like a curious puppy, and the image of her appeared in my head like some holy vision: her small face peppered with freckles, teeth missing, hair long and smooth. My heart sank.
“Yeah. Yeah, it is, but she’s got one of those lanterns, Ro. Like an old timey princess.”
She smiled down the line, the curve of her mouth audible from miles away.
“I’ve uh…I’ve got a job. It’s at a mill," I continued.
“Like a windmill?”
“Not really. It makes wood and stuff. For building.”
“Are you gonna build me something?”
”Yeah,” I said, mostly to hear her tone brighten again. “I’ll build you something. A birdhouse.”
The line went quiet for a second. "Can it be blue?"
"Can what be blue?"
"The birdhouse. Blue's my favorite now. Not pink anymore." She said it like a confession.
"Blue's a good colour," I said. "Blue's a great colour."
"Dad says pink is a girl colour and blue is a boy colour but I don't believe him because Aunt Cheryl's car is blue and she's not a boy, so I don't know why birds would care."
I pressed the back of my hand against my mouth to muffle the sound that fell out of me. "Yeah," I managed. "Birds don't care much about that stuff."
"Are you gonna paint your room blue too? When you come back?"
I closed my eyes. Somewhere behind me I could hear Nana's trowel scraping against the flowerbed border, a rhythmic little sound, and I understood with a lurch that she'd hear every word of this if I wasn't careful, that the kitchen door was only a door and not a wall.
"I don't know if I'm coming back to that room, Ro," I said, voice dropping several decibels.
"Why not?" She whispered back.
That's the thing about little siblings that I hate. They know more than they say. They absorb things like a sponge, like an old oak never grows back a branch it had clipped as a sapling.
"It's complicated, bug."
"That's what Dad says too. He says it's complicated and then he doesn't say anything else, and Mom just goes and does the dishes even though they're already clean." She paused then, and I thought I could hear the toe of her shoes scraping the floor. "Did you do something bad?"
She asked with no accusation in it at all. If she'd asked cruelly I could've hated her for it, just for a second, just enough to make it easier. Instead I had to stand there in Nana's front hall with the phone cord wound twice around my wrist, stumbling over a half-baked answer.
"No," I said. "I didn't do anything bad. I just...made Dad angry. But it's not his fault. He'll realise eventually. I'm just not who he thought I was."
"Ok. I still wanna see you though. Even if Dad's mad at you."
"I know, Rosie. I want to see you too." I heard the back door creak, and my pulse kicked up like a rabbit startled from a hedge. "Hey, I gotta go, okay? Nana's coming in."
"Wait--"
"I'll call you soon. I promise."
"Okay. I miss you being loud in the house. It's too quiet now."
I didn't have anything to say to that. I said I missed her too, and I did, more than the words could carry, and then I put the phone back in its cradle just as the screen door swung open and Nana stepped through with dirt on her knees and a fistful of cut zinnias, orange and red, the color of the sun going down.
"Who was that?" she asked, not looking up as she shook the dirt from the stems into the sink.
"Wrong number," I said.
She hummed, noncommittal, as I stood there a moment longer with my hand still resting on the phone, feeling the last warmth of the receiver fade under my palm. The wind blew open the curtains, and through the crack between them, the sky was turning a dark, bruised blue.
I went upstairs that night with a knot sat deep in my belly like an anchor that had not yet dropped to its deepest point: and I dreaded the point where it would plunge even further. My denim clad legs swayed on the stair, all the way to the bed where they curled under me like the wonky limbs of a bird. My glasses had been returned to Nana's medicine cabinet, so the sky beyond the plain brown curtains was an indigo-blue smear, smattered with white lights and the blinking green light of a jet engine.
I lay back on the bed like a creaking marionette, legs extending stiffly, arms laid across chest like a corpse. I kept my head propped up on the worn pillows, exhaling one long breath, but never really letting my shoulders drop. Dinner sat in my belly, the savory taste of potatoes and sausage curdling in my mouth like lemons in milk. I did not know why Rosie’s call had shaken me so much: or worse, I did, and avoiding it on a cellular level.
There was a sound outside like thunder, and I lifted myself off the comforter and turned towards my open window. Warm air still emanated from the crack, laced with the cold ribbons of rainwater falling from on high. The sky flashed, and the old apple tree in Nana’s yard swayed violently. The dog from two doors down howled, Barley, a young golden retriever, eager and yappy.
Then, without better reason, I slipped out of the open window and seated myself on the small sliver of roof beneath it. The shingles were slick beneath me, but my jeans were heavy and did not slide, and the rain hit my face like holy water. The knot in my stomach almost loosened as I tilted my head back up towards the navy blue smear above me, sprinkled with stars and falling tears. I imagined Robin’s head set against my shoulder, and for five sacred minutes, I was awash with joy.
When I opened my eyes to another crack of thunder, all the yard was alight.
The dry spell’s curse upon a spark was not thwarted by a small shower: the fire spread all the same, creeping down the old tree like a great orange caterpillar, reaching its many fingered hand towards the grass and extending in countless directions. The sudden whoosh of heat reached me even as I sat on the roof, and sense overcame me all at once.
I closed my eyes and jumped. Not into the fire, I was not at that time looking to die, but to escape, to scramble away from the alley behind the fence where that small patch of roof deposited me. I had thought about it before, sneaking out like this, but found myself paralyzed by guilt or fear I could not say. I found my sneakers insufficient for the impact, canvas tearing on the dirt path as I ran and felt the ache of my legs moving alongside the shockingly intense ache of freedom all at once.
It is an odd feeling to find nothing tethers you when you leave it, part from disbelief, from joy, from the eternal self-hatred that stems from the realisation that you could have done this sooner, and it wouldn’t have mattered all the same. I ran until I got to the lumber mill, fire firmly behind me, and maybe an hour until anyone found out.
I paused for a second. Nana didn’t deserve to die, devoid of grandchild and comfort, I thought. The grief of what I had done rocked me to my core then, so much so that I sank to my knees right there, in front of the shitty vending machine, praying to backlit rows of stale Lay’s and flat sodas. Somewhere behind me, nature raged on, birds’ calls and jackal screams, mating calls and warning calls to the colony all the same, melting into one great soundscape as images of Nana burning up flooded my mind like a holy vision.
A sound stirred me from my sacrilegious rumination, softer than animal and rougher than human. Robin, enrobed in the half-primal state of sleep and a torn up sleeping bag, huddled in the small office of the mill. Under the desk, she looked almost like those photos from the 1950s, of schoolchildren sheltering from bombs overhead. I called out to her and rocked her softly.
She did not respond.
I began to wonder if she had ever been anything but a dream this whole time.
My fingers had barely grazed Robin's cheek, gliding across the soft skin of her cheek like the hull of a boat cuts through a wave, when I thought I heard her breathe. A single strand of strawberry blonde hair tickled her face. I left her curled up in the sleeping bag, green and fleece-lined like a giant chrysalis. I sat back on my heels and let the office swallow me whole, cinderblock and diesel and the tang of sawdust gone stale in the heat. Somewhere beyond the walls, sirens finally found their voice, thin and far off, chasing a fire that had already had its first full meal. I did not go to them. I could not make my legs carry me back toward the orange light crowning the trees, not yet, not while Robin lay there like something washed up by a tide only I could see.
"Robin." I said it again, quieter this time, like a question I was afraid to have answered wrong.
Her eyes opened slow, gum-stuck with sleep, and for a second she looked at me like I was a stranger standing in her doorway with a knife. Then something in her face softened, folded back into itself, and she pushed up onto one elbow.
"El?" Her voice cracked down the middle. "What time is it? What's that smell?"
"Smoke," I said, and even saying it out loud made my chest go tight, the word carrying weight enough to crush a rib. "Nana's house. There was a storm, and the tree, and I don't--I don't know if she got out."
Robin was on her feet before I finished the sentence, sleeping bag pooling at her ankles like a shed skin. She didn't ask why I was here instead of there. She didn't ask why my sneakers were torn through at the toe, or why my hands shook the way old men's hands shake, loose and useless at my sides. She just took my face in both her palms, sawdust and salt and the ghost of algae still on her skin from the creek, and made me look at her.
"Hey. Hey, look at me. We're gonna call it in, and we're gonna go, and whatever's there, we're gonna deal with it. You hear me?"
I nodded, though I didn't believe a word of it.
She found Hank's office phone still plugged into the wall behind a stack of invoices, dialed with fingers that trembled only slightly more than mine, and gave the dispatcher the address in a voice gone flat and businesslike. When she hung up she didn't let go of my hand. She laced her fingers through mine instead, calloused palm against my too-soft one, and pulled me toward the door.
"Truck's out front," she said.
The night had gone strange and orange at the edges, the rain finally slacking to a drizzle that did nothing against the blaze eating its way through Nana's yard. We drove with the windows down, ash drifting in like grey snow that didn't belong to any season, and I watched it settle on my knuckles and thought, absurdly, of Rosie asking if the birdhouse could be blue, as we sailed far past Nana's house, the ghost of the flames and the mill, and onto the open road beyond us.
We drove for near an hour before Robin's truck made a sputtering sound that sounded enough like a death rattle to worry the both of us. She pulled off at a gas station sitting alone on the shoulder of the highway, its sign flickering between GAS and REST STOP so that it read half of both, over and over, GA, STOP, like it couldn't decide which one it wanted to be. The lot was empty save for a rusted ice machine humming to itself and a moth-eaten dog asleep under the propane cage. Robin cut the engine and just sat there a second, both hands still on the wheel, knuckles pale under the sodium light.
"You need gas or you need a minute?" I asked.
"Bit of both." She let out a breath, then pushed open her door. "C'mon. I'll buy you something."
The scent of Febreeze waging a losing battle against the burnt coffee and motor oil hit me in that artificial cleaner way I hadn't quite smelled since leaving Atlanta, the false fresh linen smell dragging me back through years of high-school hallways and changing room jury stands. The woman behind the counter glanced up from a paperback and gave us a once-over that clocked the ash still dusted into my hairline and the state of my torn sneakers. She did not comment on either. Small mercies.
Robin grabbed two waters and a bag of gas station kolaches from the warmer, and set them on the counter alongside a pack of Marlboros.
"Rough night?" the woman asked, ringing it up.
"Something like that," Robin said, and didn't elaborate, and the woman didn't comment, just handed back change and told us to drive safe, like a stock phrase out of a piece of shit Halloween decoration.
We sat outside on the curb by the propane cage, the dog stirring long enough to sniff at my ankle before deciding I wasn't worth the effort. Robin lit her cigarette on the third try, cupping her hand around her cracked Bic's flame, and passed it to me without asking if I smoked. I didn't. I took a drag anyway and coughed hard that tears sprung to my eyes, and every part of my throat burned.
"You didn't have to come with me," I said, once I had caught my breath between choked hiccups.
"I did." She took the cigarette back, studied the cherry of it like I had turned over my father's gun in my hands all those years ago, and realised that to her, the burning nub was a weapon all the same. "Besides. Where else was I gonna sleep tonight?"
I didn't say anything, but she answered anyways.
"It's better than home." The neon sign buzzed above us, GA, STOP, GA, STOP, and somewhere out past the treeline a siren finally gave up and went quiet, its work done or abandoned.
I unwrapped a kolache. "I keep thinking about Rosie."
"Yeah?"
"I told her I'd build her a birdhouse." I looked down at my palms, ash-grey under the streetlight, my nails torn ragged from the fence I'd scrambled over. "Feels like a stupid thing to be thinking about right now."
"It's not stupid." Robin knocked her shoulder against mine. "You miss her." She stubbed the cigarette out against the curb and flicked it into the gravel. "You're gonna see her again."
I wanted to believe her the way I did when she phoned 911, believeing in the woman twice her age living behind her eyes for just long enough to get us through. I nodded instead of answering, because my throat had gone tight again, and this time it wasn't the cigarette's fault. She stood, brushed the gravel dust from the seat of her jeans, and held a hand down to pull me up. "Truck's got maybe half a tank now. We'll get further this time."
Georgia let go of us somewhere past Toccoa, the pines thinning into low hills that rolled up into the Carolinas like a long, green-grey exhale. I watched the state line sign flick past in the dark, reflective letters catching Robin's headlights for half a second before the black swallowed it again, and I felt something in my chest ease loos. We didn't say anything about it. She just reached over without looking and turned the radio dial until she found a station that wasn't all static and preaching, and left her hand resting on the bench seat between us, palm up, an invitation I took without hesitation
The kolaches were long gone by the time the fuel light blinked on again outside Spartanburg, and Robin's shoulders had started that particular slump that meant she was running on fumes same as the truck. I offered to drive. She laughed at that, and said she wasn't about to hand over the wheel of her one worldly possession to my noodle arms with a learner's permit two years expired. Somewhere around one in the morning, with the sky gone that flat, starless black, she pulled off at a motel called the Bluebird Inn, its sign missing the D so that it read BLUEBIR INN in tired pink neon, one bulb stuttering, like a distant cousin to the rest stop.
The woman at the desk took Robin's cash wordlessly, counted out chang, and slid a brass key across the counter attached to a plastic tag shaped like a duck.
"Ice machine's broke," she said, by way of goodnight, and went back to her television.
Room 6 was almost glamourous to Robin and I, bigger than truck-bed at least, and that was enough. There were two double beds with matching floral spreads, orange and brown flowers that had probably been fashionable sometime around Nana's wedding, and a television bolted to the dresser with a coat hanger doing the job a proper antenna should have. Robin dropped her bag at the foot of the far bed and sat down hard.
"We made it," she said.
"Halfway, maybe." I sat on the other bed, the springs complaining under me, and looked at my own hands in the lamplight. There was ash still worked into the creases of my knuckles, grey lines like the beginnings of a map sketched in hraphite. "You said DC. Why DC?"
"Cousin of mine's up there." She peeled her boots off one at a time, letting them thud to the carpet. "You got somewhere better?"
I didn't. I had a birdhouse I'd promised to build and no return address to send it to, and beyond that, nothing that could rightly be called a plan.
"No," I admitted. "DC's fine. DC's good."
She smiled at that, and reached over to switch off the lamp between us. In the dark the air conditioner kept up its complaint, and I lay there listening to Robin's breathing even out beside me, feeling the day settle into my bones like sediment. I thought of Nana's house, whether it still stood or whether it had gone the way of the tree, whether she'd gotten out in time, whether she'd even tried the way I hadn't stayed to find out.
I thought of Rosie's voice asking if the birdhouse could be blue.
"You awake?" Robin's voice came soft through the dark, barely there over the rattle of the AC.
"Yeah."
"We're gonna be okay." She didn't reach for my hand this time. "I've done this before. It gets easier once you stop looking back at the thing you left."
I didn't answer her. I lay there instead and watched the stuttering pink light from the sign outside bleed faintly through the gap in the curtains, painting the popcorn ceiling in slow pulses, on and off, on and off, like an off-kilter heartbeat. Eventually the light didn't matter anymore, because I'd stopped seeing it, sleep pulling me under the way the creek water had pulled at my ankles that day that felt now like it belonged to some other, earlier version of myself.
I woke in Room 6 of the Bluebird Inn to a light that did not know me. It came through the gap in the curtains thin and white, laying itself across the orange and brown flowers of the bedspread like a surgeon's hand, and for one soft, stupid second I believed I was in Nana's house, that the rose-coloured mornings had simply gone sour overnight, and that downstairs the bacon was already spitting in its pan. Then I smelt it. Smoke, thick in the weave of my father's shirt, in my hair, in the creases of my knuckles where the grey had set like a map of some country I had burned down myself, and the whole of the night came back to me in a single swallowed breath.
Robin was already awake. She sat cross-legged on the other bed with a plastic bag from the vending alcove spilled open at her knees, and she was eating pretzels one at a time. Her hair had come loose from its clip in the night and stood out around her head in a copper halo, sawdust still lodged in it.
"Morning, doll," she said. "You talk in your sleep."
"What did I say?"
"Mostly stuff about your Nana." She tossed a pretzel at me, and I did not catch it, because without my glasses the world beyond arm's length was a watercolour left out in the rain, and her hand and the pretzel and the grin were all one warm smear that I had to take on faith. "I didn't wake you. Figured you were busy."
I picked the pretzel off the comforter and held it in my hands until it went sticky. Somewhere beyond the wall a pipe knocked twice, and the television, which had been left on at some point in the dark, hissed its static into the room, a grey ocean with nothing living in it.
"I can't keep wearing this," I said, and plucked at the shirt, at the sleeve that fell past my wrist, at the collar that had hung off my collarbones for six weeks like a hand that would not let go. It was a good shirt, once. Blue check, soft with washing, a man's shirt that had known a man's shoulders, my father's, packed into a suitcase by my mother's hand with all the tenderness of someone folding a flag at a funeral. It stank now of cinders and the inside of a wardrobe, and still, beneath all of it, the faint cedar ghost of his aftershave, and I could not tell which smell I wanted to be rid of more.
Robin looked at me for a long moment, chewing. Then she wiped her salty fingers on her jeans and rose, and rummaged through the duffel at the foot of her bed until she came up with a flannel, red and black, the elbows gone thin as paper with one button missing at the cuff.
"It's mine. It'll be big on you too, but it'll be big in a different way."
I did not understand what she meant until I put it on. It hung off me just as the other had, loose across the shoulders and long in the arm, floppy like a lent thing, a thing handed across a table by a hand that wanted you to keep it. It smelt of the apricot soap Robin used in the creek, and of her. I took the blue check shirt and folded it, because I could not help folding it, because even then some obedient and terrible part of me thought it ought to be treated with respect. Then I carried it to the wastebasket by the dresser and let it fall. It made no sound at all. I had expected thunder.
Robin turned to me then, holding something small and silver, and it took me a moment, squinting, to see that it was a pair of nail scissors, the sort that come in a gas station grooming kit in a plastic wallet with a comb the size of a thumb. "Sit down, El. Your hair looks like a dog got at it."
"Nana did it."
"I know she did."
I sat on the edge of the bed, in the weak white light, and Robin stood behind me, and I felt the scissors before I heard them. It was a small cold touch at the nape of my neck, so close to what Nana had done on that first sun-soaked morning that my whole body locked, the muscles drawing up my spine like a hand drawn into a fist, the old words rising unbidden in my ears: country hick mullet, doll, it's for your own good. I shut my eyes. I thought, absurdly, of the photograph over the mantel, the deer's stiff bristled flank, and the gap-toothed smile of a man who I had never met.
"Hey." Robin's free hand settled on my shoulder. "You say stop and I stop. That's the whole deal. You hear me?"
"I hear you."
"Say it, then."
"Stop," I said, testing it in my mouth, a small and foreign word, and the scissors lifted at once, held still in the air as if the room itself had drawn breath.
"Okay," Robin said. "Okay. Do you want me to?"
I thought about it. I thought about it for longer than I have ever thought about anything, longer than I had thought about the distance between the roof and the gruound and my body, longer than I had thought about Nana, and I understood that this was the first time in my nineteen years that anyone had put the scissors in my hands, even if she was the one holding them.
"Yes," I said. "Please. Not short. Just make it tidy."
The first lock fell across my knee. It was dark and coarse, the colour of wet bark, and I watched it lie there in the lap of the red flannel like something that had belonged to a stranger. Then another fell, and another, with the scissors whispering their soft song, and Robin hummed beneath her breath, the same tuneless song she'd hummed on the hood of the truck while the metal ticked and cooled. Somewhere behind my ribs, the anchor that had hung so long in the cold dark of me gave one small, shuddering shift, and did not drop. When she was finished she turned me by the shoulders towards the bathroom, and I stood before the mirror above the sink, spotted and silvering at the edges, and I could see nothing of myself at all. A smudge. A pale oval, a dark frame around it, a red slash that might have been a shoulder. A face I had not seen clearly in six weeks, perhaps in nineteen years, and now could not see for lack of lenses.
I leaned in until my nose almost touched the glass, and breathed a small cloud onto it, and in the clearing I caught a single blurry eye looking back at me, and it was, God help me, my own.
"Well?" Robin said from the doorway.
"I can't see," I said, and laughed and then sobbed, and she crossed the cracked linoleum in two strides and held me while it passed, one hand cradling the back of my head, her fingers in the new ragged ends of my hair. "I can't see a thing, Robin."
"You don't have to," she said into my crown. "I can."
We checked out of the Bluebird Inn at ten, and I left the duck key tag on the counter with the woman and her television. She did not look up. In the lot, Robin held the truck door for me with a flourish, a bow, one hand sweeping toward the bench seat like a footman.
“Milady,” she said.
“Don’t.”
“Milord,” she tried, and watched my face. Whatever she found there drop the ruse immediately, smiling apologetically. “El,” she said. “Get in, El.”
I got in. I would have followed that voice off the edge of the map.
North Carolina rolled by, tobacco barns leaning in the fields like tired men, kudzu swallowing telephone poles whole. With my hair cropped short, the wind through the window found my neck for the first time in six weeks and I kept touching the place with my fingertips.
“Better?” she asked.
“It's cold.”
“You look like James Dean’s lesbian sister," Robin said, and I laughed so hard I had to put my head against the dashboard.
Around noon the truck started coughing again, and Robin patted the wheel and told it to hold on a little longer, sweet-talking it like a horse. We pulled into a town called Lenoir Creek. The flags on the porches were very bright. I noticed them even through the blur, red-white-blue smears hanging still in the heat.
“Eat first, gas after,” Robin said. “I’m shaking.”
Under the table, her knee found mine and stayed there, maintaining contact just long enough to make me look up and check on her. When I did, her face had gone stone-serious. “I’m gonna say something, and you can be as scared as you want.”
“Okay," I said, dragging my fry through a puddle of ketchup, before deciding that whatever this was, deserved eye contact.
“I’m not doing this for the cousin in DC.” She looked at the ketchup bottle, then at me. “I had my bag packed for two years, El. I just didn’t have anywhere to go with it. Then a skinny kid in a dead man’s shirt walked in the mill and lied to me about a sandwich.”
“Robin.”
“And I thought, oh no. There it is.”
I reached across the table. My hand shook, and I took her calloused fingers in mine, and I held them. Then I lifted them to my mouth and kissed her knuckles, one by one, the way I’d seen in films when the film wasn’t about people like us. The waitress was watching. I felt her eyes on us the way cold air seeps in under a door, and you don't know how cold it's gotten until your feet go numb. I let go of Robin’s hand and then, stubbornly, took it back.
“Check, please,” Robin said, loudly and pleasantly.
It was in the parking lot that she kissed me.
The sun was high, and the heat came up off the asphalt in waves. Robin pushed me gently back against the warm side of the truck and put both hands either side of my head, and kissed me slowly, like she had all the time in the world, like the dead creek and the dry spell and the fire were all behind us and nobody had ever taught us shame. My hands found her waist. Her mouth tasted like salt and sweet tea. When she pulled back, she was smiling, forehead pressed to mine.
“There,” she said. “Now you’re mine and the whole town knows.”
“The whole town,” I said, “is a parking lot.”
Then came the footsteps. Without my glasses they were only shapes: three, maybe four, dark and heavy-footed. I felt Robin go still beside me. Her hand dropped from my face to my wrist and tightened.
“Get in the truck, El,” she said, very quiet.
“Hey,” a voice called, pleasant, almost friendly. “Hey, girls.”
“Get in the truck.”
“Which one of you’s the boy?” Another voice, higher, laughing. “I can’t tell. Is that one a boy or a girl?”
The word girl hit me where it always hit, a hook set under the ribs, tugging at my diaphragm until it felt like my lungs were on fire and my throat was burning. It was not a thing I had felt since The Event.
“Robin,” I whispered.
“Truck. Now.”
She tried to get me to the door, but one of the shapes was suddenly there and Robin was suddenly in front of me, and I heard her say “Back off,” in the flat businesslike voice she had used with the 911 dispatcher, and then I heard the other voice say a word. I will not write it here. I have never been able to write it, not when it isn't in her voice, because in his, it hit like a fist holding a hammer, throwing its weight indiscriminately.
I couldn’t see most of what followed, only the blurred flurry of colours and sounds, boots hitting flesh, and something cracking, the crunch of gravel, and Robin's grunt as something struck the metal body of the truck. Someone grabbed the collar of the flannel and I was on the ground, the asphalt burning my palms, with a weight on my back, a hand in my short hair holding my face to the ground. Not so tough now, someone said in my ear, not so tough, sweetheart.
I did what I had always done when I was hurt. I went somewhere else. I went to the hood of the truck at the creek, Robin humming beside me.
And then I heard her scream my name, El, over and over, like a siren in the rain.
It anchored me. I got my knees under me and bit down on the arm across my throat until I tasted copper. I scrambled up, blind and screaming, swinging at shapes. A fist connected with my mouth and the world went white. When the white cleared I was on my back looking up at a sky I could not focus on, and somebody was laughing, and somebody else said come on, that’s enough, Dale, come on, and boots moved off across the lot.
I heard a woman’s voice, quiet in the far away: I’m calling the sheriff.
“El.” Robin’s face swam into the blur above me, close enough to see. One of her eyes was swelling shut, and blood ran from her nose in a thin line into the corner of her mouth. Her hair was loose, and sawdust, impossibly, still glinted in it. “El, honey, look at me. Look at me. Can you hear me?”
“I can see you,” I said, through a split lip. It came out slurred and ridiculous. “Robin, I can see you.”
She laughed, and it turned into a sob, and she bent over me and pressed her forehead to mine, and I felt her shaking against me.
“I’m sorry,” she said. “I’m so sorry. I shouldn’t have...”
“Don’t.”
“I kissed you in a parking lot, El. In Carolina. I knew better. I’ve always known better.”
“Robin.” I found her face with my scraped hands, held it. “You kissed me in the sun. I’d do it again.”
She stared at me, blood and tears making tracks in the dust on her cheeks. Then she kissed me, very carefully, on my cut mouth, so lightly it barely touched.
The waitress came out eventually, wiping her hands on her apron, and stood a few feet away, her face a pale circle atop a body whose language I could not read. She held out a dishtowel full of ice, and a bottle of water, and then, after a long moment, a brown paper bag.
“The sheriff’ll be forty minutes,” she said. “He’s Dale’s uncle.” She set the bag at Robin’s feet like an offering at a shrine. “Gas is down the road at the Sunoco. Mr. Pruitt doesn’t talk much. He’ll fill your tank and not ask. You don’t want to be here when that boy’s friends come back.”
“Why are you helping us?” Robin asked, hoarsely.
The waitress looked at the two of us, bloodied on the hot asphalt in each other’s arms, and she stilled for a moment.
“My brother,” she said, and nothing else. She went back inside.
Robin drove with one eye, her jaw set, a bag of ice pressed to her cheek. The paper bag sat between us on the bench seat, and when I opened it there were two slices of pecan pie wrapped in wax paper, and a ten-dollar bill folded very small. We did not speak until Lenoir Creek had shrunk to a smudge in the mirror, the water tower thinning to a silver needle on the horizon. Then Robin reached across, without looking, and laid her hand on the seat between us. Palm up. Waiting.
I took it. My knuckles were split, and so were hers. We left bloody prints on the vinyl.
“We’re gonna be okay,” she said.
“I know,” I said.
I ate the pie with my fingers carefully, because the filling stung where my flesh was open. Somewhere north of us, a cousin’s couch waited in a city I’d only seen in school textbooks, and behind us, in a flat Georgia field, the ashes were cooling. I touched my cropped hair, my swollen mouth, the red flannel. All that I’d lost, and all of it still mine.
The sky ahead was turning that dark, bruised blue.
Her hand was warm, I remember thinking, dissolving into the feeling of it for a few seconds, the crackling radio bleeding song into the air around us. The windows were up, out of fear more than anything, and the world slid past in a hazy blur, heat rising in the truck cabin. My head lolled back on the headrest, cracked leather cold on my exposed nape, and my eyes fluttered closed admist the gentle hum of the road beneath us, and the feeling of her fingers around mine.
I woke up in Atlanta with eyes heavy from weed and a throat dry from sleeplessness. Slumped in a beanbag, all limbs and bleary eyes, Jenny May lay across from me, and all of it came back over me like a crashing wave. Biggie Smalls thumped over a speaker somewhere behind me, and the terrible clarity of my own vision overwhelmed me: the scarlet marks on Jen’s neck, the stark corners of my own shirtless body as I sat with my head propped up against the wall, the omnipresent ticking that lived in the house, from Dad’s footsteps downstairs to the sound of Rosie playing in the next room. My glasses lay crooked across my nose, and all of me was sticky with sweat as I rose, and Jenny stayed exactly where she was, beside a condom that must have been used, and barely looked like it.
I remembered this, even sharper, as the guilt came back and prodded at my ribs.
It was not Jenny's fault. I knew that, even then. She had been kind to me; laughed at my jokes and let me put my hands on her hips and had kissed me in the dark while the stereo played. She had told me I was handsome, and I had believed her for the length of a song, perhaps two, because I wanted so badly to be the sort of boy a girl might want that I had mistaken being wanted for wanting.
When I looked at her now, asleep in the corner of my room, I could not remember what I had felt when I kissed her. I remembered the effort it had taken. The careful positioning of my hands, the way I had watched her face for signs that I was doing something right, the relief that came whenever she made a noise that suggested I was. I remembered thinking about what my father would say if he could see me, and then thinking about how proud he might be, and hating myself for wanting him to be proud of me at all.
Jenny stirred, her cheek dragging against the faded fabric of the beanbag. For a moment, I thought she was going to wake, and I braced myself to open the conversation. With an apology, perhaps. Or a joke.
Instead, she rolled onto her side and went back to sleep.
I envied her that.
I pulled my shirt over my head. It was inside out, and the collar caught on my glasses, nearly pulling them from my face. I swore under my breath and fumbled with the fabric until I could see properly again. The room focussed into its familiar ugliness: the plastic cups on my nightstand, the ashtray overflowing with cigarette ends, the curtains drawn against the morning sun. A photograph of my family sat crooked on the desk, taken at Christmas three years earlier. My mother had her hand on Dad's shoulder. Rosie was perched on his knee, grinning with two missing front teeth. I stood behind them, taller than everyone else, my hair swept back from my forehead, one hand resting on the back of the sofa.
I wondered when I had become such a convincing liar.
I went to the bathroom and shut the door.
The mirror above the sink was merciless. My eyes were red, my hair stuck up at the crown, and there was a dark mark along my collarbone that I could not remember acquiring. I turned my head to examine it, then looked away before I could begin to imagine what it meant. I washed my face in cold water and brushed my teeth twice. The toothpaste burnt more than I remembered.
I left and sat beside Jenny until she woke. She blinked at me, squinting in the daylight, and gave me a sleepy smile.
"Hey."
"Hey."
"Did I fall asleep here?"
"Looks like it."
She laughed softly, rubbing her eyes. "God, my Mom’s going to kill me."
She sat up, gathered her clothes from the floor, and dressed behind the door like someone who had nothing to hide from herself. When she came back around, she leaned down and kissed my cheek.
"Call me later, okay?"
"Okay."
She paused, searching my face for something. I wondered if she could see it: , the knowledge that we could have stayed there for another hour, another night, another year, and she still never would have found what she had been looking for.
She left a half-hour later, through the front door with her shoes in one hand and her hair falling loose around her face.
I watched her go from the window.
Dad was wearing the blue check shirt when I came downstairs. It was a Thursday, and he wore it on Thursdays, because Thursdays were the day he worked from home. He sat at the head of the kitchen table with the newspaper folded into quarters, one thumb hooked in the handle of his mug, and the cedar of his aftershave moved through the room ahead of him like weather.
"El." He did not look up. "You look like hell."
"Late night."
"Studying?"
"Yes, sir."
The paper rustled. I remember thinking that he knew. Mom stood at the counter with her back to us, buttering toast with great concentration, and the radio on the windowsill murmured about traffic on the Connector. Rosie sat across from me with her feet not quite touching the floor, eating cereal milk moustache clinging to her upper lip.
"You're gonna miss the bus," she said instead.
"Thanks, bug."
Dad lowered the paper, finally, and studied me over the top of it. His eyes were grey, the same grey as mine, the only thing of his I had ever been glad to have inherited. "You need to shave," he said. "Come here."
"I'm fine."
"Elliot."
I went. He set down his mug and turned my chin in his hand, tilting my face toward the window light the way he might have examined a board for warp, and ran his thumb along my jaw, where the fuzz had come in. His palm was dry and warm. For one second the tenderness of it undid me completely, because it was tenderness, I would swear it in any court, he was not a cruel man, and I felt the old terrible wish rise in me to lean into that hand and be, in truth, the son it was reaching for.
"Man's got to keep himself up," he said. "People notice."
"Yes, sir."
"Good lad." He patted my cheek twice, lightly, and went back to his paper, and I took my bag and went out into a morning too bright for my eyes, and did not once, I think, breathe out until the front door closed behind me.
I took the bus seat by the window, third from the back, and pulled the hood of my sweatshirt up over my head, and watched Atlanta go by in streaks. Without the glasses I could have blurred it all into watercolour, but I had put them on in the hall, because Dad liked it when I looked like I was paying attention, and so every billboard and gas-station sign came at me knife-sharp. I pressed my forehead to the glass and let it rattle my teeth.
Marcus Tillery slid into the seat beside me at the stop on Peachtree and bumped my shoulder with his, hard enough to be friendly. "Hanson. Hanson, my man. Tell me you didn't."
"Didn't what?"
"Walters's car was in your driveway at, like, one in the morning. Dev drove past." He grinned like a boy who had found a wallet. "Well?"
This was the part I knew how to do. You raised one eyebrow. You let a smile begin at the corner of your mouth and then, with great and noble restraint, you stopped it. I had studied the technique the way other people study for the SATs, on the faces of boys in the cafeteria, in the dialogue of movies, in the particular tilt of my father's head when he said a gentleman doesn't.
"A gentleman doesn't," I said.
Marcus howled. He grabbed the back of my neck and shook me like a puppy, and three rows up a girl turned to look, and I smiled for her too.
"Walters," Marcus breathed, with reverence. "God. Hanson, you absolute legend."
I looked out of the window. The sky over the interstate was the colour of dishwater, and in the glass I caught my own reflection laid over the passing buildings, hooded, bespectacled, nondescript, and for the length of a single stoplight I saw something else looking back. It was only a trick of the angle and the light, the pale oval of a face with the hood framing it differently, and then the bus lurched forward and it was gone, and I was a boy with a split-ends fuzz of beard and a good reputation.
In the locker room I changed in the stall.
I had done it so long that nobody remarked on it anymore. I stood with my back against the cold metal partition and my gym shirt balled in my fist and listened to the room outside: the slam of lockers, the snap of towels, Marcus holding forth on the subject of Jenny's collarbones to an audience of appreciative grunts. My name came up twice. I pulled the shirt on over my head and bit the inside of my cheek until I stopped shaking.
In English we were reading The Great Gatsby, and Mrs. Alvarado called the roll with her pen hovering over the sheet.
"Hanson, Elliot."
"Here."
It came out of my mouth in my own voice, which was lower than I wanted and softer than the boys' voices, and I had spent years sanding the edges of it. The word here hung in the air a moment too long, as if the room were waiting for the person it belonged to to come and claim it. Elliot. It was such an ordinary name. Soft in the middle, with a good, solid t at the end to hold it all down, like the weight on the corner of a tablecloth. My mother had chosen it. She had told me once that she picked it out of a book, that it meant , and I had nodded, knowing full well that she had never been religious.
Jenny sat three desks over by the window. She had washed her hair since morning, and it hung damp and dark against the collar of her cardigan. I'm sorry, I thought at her, furiously. I'm sorry, I'm sorry, you deserved someone who wanted you the way you're wanted.
She mouthed hey.
I mouthed it back.
I ate lunch in the third-floor stairwell.
The concrete was cold through my jeans. I unwrapped the sandwich Mom had packed, peanut butter and grape jelly with the crusts cut off, as if I were still six, and I ate it slowly, with my glasses pushed up into my hair and the whole world dissolving pleasantly at arm's length. The stairwell window held a square of pale sky. Somewhere below me a door boomed, and a hundred voices rose and fell like surf.
I took out my phone and opened the notes app and the list hit me like a truck, a memory through time that left me wobbling with my ankles in the shallows with a current that could knock you over, deep end or not. It held names, some of them crossed out, some of them circled, some checked with an 'x' next to them which I could not recall if that marked them for promotion or deletion. Some were from books. One was Rosie's middle name. One was my grandmother's, which I'd typed and deleted three times before leaving it, misspelled this time. Madelynn instead of Madeleine.
Ella, I had typed, a month ago, at the top of the list, and not crossed it out.
When I got home that afternoon, Rosie was on the front step with a piece of sidewalk chalk, drawing a house with four windows and a blue door. She looked up as I came through the gate.
"Dad says I can't have a blue door," she announced. "He says doors are brown."
I crouched beside her and took a stub of chalk from the box. "Why can't a door be blue?"
"That's what I said."
I drew a window on her house, and then a smaller one in the attic, and then, because there was room, a tiny round window beneath the eaves where nobody would think to look.
"Who lives in there?" Rosie asked.
"I don't know yet," I said. "Somebody."
I must have slept in the dream, and my mind must have decided to make things worse because I woke up and it was a Thursday again, and Dad was in the blue check shirt at the head of the table with his paper folded into quarters. Rosie sat across from me with her legs swinging, and I must've gotten up and forgotten to turn my phone off, because she was reading aloud as she ate, sounding out a word, each syllable landing like a gavel.
“Ella,” she said. “Who’s Ella? There’s a whole list of people. Is she El’s girlfriend?”
The radio on the windowsill went on about the Connector. Mom’s knife stopped halfway across the toast.
I think I might have laughed. Dad lowered the paper, and she passed him the phone with a pleased helpfulness. He read for a long time, thumb moving down the screen. I watched his face for the thing I had always been afraid of, and it never came.
“Rosanna,” he said. “Go and brush your teeth.”
She went, looking back at us from the door. When her feet had gone up the stairs he set the phone down on the table, very gently, face up, so that all of us could see.
“What is this?” Dad said.
I could have said it was a story for English. I could have said it was a joke, that it was Marcus’s, that it was for a girl I liked. I had a whole shelf of lies and I knew where each one was kept, and I stood in that kitchen with every one of them within reach and found that my hands would not lift.
“It’s mine,” I said.
“Elliot.”
“It’s mine,” I said again, and the word mine felt like something I had pushed through a wall, and on the other side of it nobody moved.
Mom put down the knife. She turned to the sink and ran the tap over a plate that was already clean.
“You’ll go to school,” Dad said at last. His voice was level, with effort, like a man holding a door against a wind. “You’ll go to school and you’ll keep your head down, and tonight we’ll discuss this as a family. Is that understood?”
“Dad--”
“Is that understood?”
“Yes, sir.”
He picked up his keys. He did not take his mug. The truck started in the drive, and I listened to it all the way down the street, until I could not tell it from the traffic.
I do not remember school. I remember that Mrs Alvarado called the roll, and Marcus slapped my back at lunch. Jenny mouthed hey, and I mouthed it back, and neither of them could see that I was no longer in the room. I was somewhere up near the ceiling, watching a tall boy with good manners eat a sandwich with the crusts cut off, and wondering what would happen to him tonight.
The house was empty when I got home. Mom’s car was gone, and there was a note on the kitchen counter: Taking Rosie to Cheryl’s. Dad will be home late. Eat something.
I ate nothing. I went upstairs and sat on my bed with my shoes on, and then got up again.
My parents’ bedroom smelt of cedar and clean laundry. The closet was on the left, and on the high shelf behind Dad’s good jacket sat the grey lockbox I had known about since I was thirteen, the year he put the thing inside it into my hands in the back garden. Respect it, he had said, and I had held it for what felt like an hour and was probably a minute. I remembered thinking that if I only held it correctly, I would turn into the person it was meant for.
I took the box down. I knew the code. Everybody in that house knew the code.
It was heavier than I remembered. Colder, too. Six years had passed and I had grown into my hands, and still it sat in them like a foreign thing, a holy bent piece of metal with crude machinery inside it. I carried it to my own room.
The bralette was at the bottom of the third drawer, balled inside a sock inside a boot. It was pale blue, plain cotton, bought with birthday money from a Target two bus rides away, in a hurry, at the register with my face turned from the cashier. I had worn it twice. I set the gun down on the bed, on the quilt, beside the pillow, and I looked at it there, small and dark against the patchwork.
Then I took off Dad’s old shirt, the one I’d borrowed from the laundry, and I took off my glasses and set them on the desk, and I put it on.
My shoulders were broader than I would have chosen, and my ribs showed. The blue was a plain colour against my skin. It was not beautiful and it did not transform me. What it did was fit, and make me think: There you are.
Then I went back to the bed and picked up the gun again. I turned it over, and over, and did not point it anywhere. I only held it. I wanted to know whether the two things could be in one room, the girl at the window and the person whose hands my father had pressed the gun into, six years ago.
I do not know how long I stood there.
I heard the car first, the particular grind of Mom’s Honda in the drive, and I did not move.
The door flew open.
“Elliot.”
She was white to the lips. Her handbag was still on her arm. She looked at me, at the blue cotton and my bare shoulders and the open curtains, and then at my hands, and everything in her face went out like a pulled plug.
“Put it down,” she said. It came out very quiet. “Baby. Put it down. Please. Please put it down.”
“Mom, I’m not--”
“Put it down.”
“I wasn’t going to.” My voice shook so badly the words came out in pieces. “I only wanted to hold it. I only wanted to see.”
“Give it to me,” she said. “Give it to Mommy.”
I do not know why I let her. I think it was the word. I think I was very tired. I held it out, and her hands closed over it and mine at once, and for a moment we were both holding it, her fingers cold and wet on my knuckles, and then I let go and it was hers. She did not look at it. She laid it on the dresser behind her without turning, and then she had me against her so hard that the buckle of her bag bit into my ribs, and she was sobbing into my neck, big dry shaking sobs, her hands moving over my back and my arms and my face.
“Oh, God,” she said. “Oh, God, baby. Oh, God.”
Baby. I stood very still inside it. It was the first time in a week that anyone had touched me without a fist or a hand-shaped question in it, and I let myself have it, one second, two, three.
Then she pulled back and saw the bralette again, and I watched the tenderness leave her face the way colour leaves a sky.
“Put something on,” she said.
“Mom.”
“Put something on. Now. Anyone could see. The Hendersons could see. I saw, from the road.” She snatched my father’s shirt off the floor and shoved it into my arms. “Is this what you wanted? Is this what all this was, for the neighbours to see you, in the window, with that, with your--”
“Nobody’s looking.”
“Don’t you tell me nobody’s looking.”
“I wasn’t doing anything to anyone.” My voice cracked in the middle. “I was just standing here. It’s mine, Mom, it’s just mine.”
“It isn’t yours.” She was shaking, and furious, and I understood with sudden clear pity that she was frightened in a way she had no words for and so had turned it into the one thing she did have words for.
She wiped her face with the heel of her hand. She breathed in, once, and I watched her put herself back together piece by piece, a woman folding a flag.
“Your father will be home at seven,” she said. “He and I are going to talk, and then we are going to call your grandmother in Macon."
“Mom, please--”
“You’ll go on Saturday.” She picked the gun up from the dresser with a cloth from her bag, held well away from herself, and I understood that she would carry it out of the room and out of my reach, and that this was her one act of mercy and she would never think of it as one.
I sat on the bed in my father’s shirt. Out on the front step, I knew, Rosie’s chalk house was waiting where she had drawn it, four windows, a blue door, a small round window under the eaves where nobody would think to look.