The table is laid with the good silver, each fork positioned perfectly, napkins wrangled into delicate swans and lilies. Marla's mother has been orchestrating this since early morning: the caterer's arrival at nine, the florist at ten, the final "walk-through" at two while Marla sits in her room pretending to catch up on holiday reading after church. She's dressed carefully. A navy dress with a neckline that isn't too conservative, and not too showy, understated jewelry, hair arranged perfectly, after forty-five minutes at her bathroom mirror with a curling wand. She looks as if she has stepped out of a magazine.
She can't quite tell if she likes it.
The guests arrive between seven and seven-fifteen. There are always exactly eight: Marla's parents, Aunt Lillian, the Hendersons from two streets over with three children at Eton, the Smiths, and the Ashworths. Brian hasn't been invited this year. Her mother said he was with Giuletta in Rome this Christmas. Marla knows from his Instagram that he is in Bristol. She knows not to bring it up: Marla's role tonight is to be present, intelligent but not showy, warm but not effusive, interesting but not attention-seeking.
She knows this.
"Marla, darling," Mrs. Henderson says, kissing her cheek. "How's St Anne's treating you? Your mother says you're doing brilliantly."
"It's been quite demanding," Marla replies, the correct level of humility in her voice. "But I'm enjoying it."
"Demanding in what way?" Mr. Smith asks.
Marla considers her answer carefully. "Academically, socially. There's a lot of... presence expected."
"That's what the best schools do," Mrs. Ashworth says, as though this is obviously positive. "They prepare you for a life where you're always being watched."
Marla only smiles.
Dinner is announced. Everyone moves to the table with a sort of choreographed ease that Marla finds slightly disconcerting without the set dressing of uniforms and class-times. Marla's mother--Emmeline--sits at one end, her father at the other, creating the illusion of democratic seating. Marla finds herself next to Aunt Lillian. The first course is soup. Everything is soup first, then fish, then meat, then something "light" for dessert. The progression is as certain as liturgy.
Marla can feel her aunt's attention like a weight. She doesn't look at her; she focuses on her soup spoon, on the precise angle she must hold it.
"You look thinner," her aunt continues. "Diminished."
"I'm managing fine," Marla says.
"You always say that."
Across the table, Mr. Smith is telling a story about his son's first term at Oxford. Everyone is laughing at the appropriate moments. Her father is nodding at something Mrs. Henderson said about the housing market. Everything is proceeding exactly as it should. Emmeline catches her eye and holds it for just a moment: be present, be appropriate. Marla nods fractionally. The check is complete.
The fish course arrives, cod, cooked to translucent flaccidity, lay upon a bed of tasteless pea and mint purée. Everyone compliments it anyway.
"Marla, I heard you might be Head Girl next year," the Ashworth daughter (Catherine? Caroline?) says. "That's extraordinary."
"Not yet," Marla replies. "The selection hasn't been finalized."
"But you're expecting to be chosen?"
"I'm hoping to be," Marla says carefully. There's a precision to this language: hope is acceptable, expectation is arrogant.
"Well, I'm sure you will be," Catherine/Caroline says. "You have that look about you."
Marla swallows around a thin fish bone. It cuts her on the way down. "That's very kind of you to say."
After dinner there's coffee in the sitting room. The men cluster near the fireplace discussing golf and cricket. The women distribute themselves across the sofas, Marla's mother fielding questions about her charity work, something to do with children's literacy, which Catherine/Caroline volleys animated questions about with a disinterested investment.
Marla sits on the edge of a sofa, coffee balanced precisely on her knee, and listens.
"You're very quiet tonight," Aunt Lillian observes, joining her on the periphery.
"Just listening," Marla says.
"To what?"
Marla considers this. "Nothing in particular."
"There's something different about you," her aunt says quietly. "Since the last time I saw you. Something's shifted."
"School's demanding," Marla offers.
"It's not that." Her aunt leans closer. "It's like you're listening to something I can't hear. Are you quite alright?"
"Yes," Marla says. "I'm fine." She pauses, fidgeting by running a nail around the rim of her saucer, considering her next move. She decides that it is a perfectly reasonable move to make, she is eighteen after all, and her Aunt will likely delight in the conspiratorial delinquency of it all. "Aunt Lillian?" She asks.
"Yes, my dear?"
"Do you have..." she lowers her voice fractionally, tilting her head downwards in such a way to not interrupt her curls, "a cigarette?"
Aunt Lillian’s smile doesn’t change, but her posture does: an infinitesimal straightening, a flicker of amusement behind the eyes. She has always enjoyed being the person Marla comes to when she wants to step half an inch outside the lines. “Of course I do,” she murmurs, as though Marla has asked for a breath mint. “But not here.”
Her hand drifts to her clutch, tapping it once with a manicured finger. Then she rises, smoothing her skirt, and says, loud enough for the room to hear, soft enough to sound incidental: “I’m going to get a bit of air.”
Marla waits three polite seconds before standing. Her mother’s assessing gaze flicks toward her, but Marla offers a serene, dutiful smile. Just stretching my legs. Emmeline nods, satisfied. The hallway is dimmer. Aunt Lillian is already at the back door, holding it open with a conspiratorial elegance. Outside, the garden is washed in moonlight, the hydrangeas pale and ghostly. The air is cool, a relief after the thick warmth of the sitting room. Aunt Lillian produces a slim silver case, flips it open, and offers it to Marla.
“Only take one,” she says lightly. “I've seen enough little girls pretend to be seasoned smokers,” she snaps the case closed. "And had enough little girls throw up on me to know when enough is enough," Aunt Lillian says, exhaling a perfect ribbon of smoke. “You are different.”
Marla looks out over the garden. “In a good way?”
“In an interesting way,” her aunt replies. “I like a girl who knows how to weigh her choices.”
Marla lets the smoke curl from her lips. “I don’t know what I’m choosing.”
“Oh, darling.” Aunt Lillian smiles. “You’re choosing yourself. That’s always the beginning.”
The kitchen has been awake since six.
Julian knows because he has been awake since five-forty, lying very still, listening to his dad move about downstairs, trying not to wake a house that was very much already awake. He mutters a word, directed at the turkey, that would earn Aria a lecture if she ever said it. By ten, every surface is occupied. The turkey rests under foil like a patient. Two pans of rice and peas steam on the back hob, and the macaroni cheese sits on the windowsill to cool, guarded by a tea towel. The windows are fogged to the corners. The whole house smells of thyme, allspice and burnt sugar.
Gran arrives at eleven with Uncle Jack carrying her shopping bags, and a cake tin--Quality Street tin, metal with the logo from the 90s--held in both hands. She peels back the lid slightly, and the scent of rum hits Julian harder than anything as he stands in the doorway. Chairs: seven, plus the folding one from the garage that Dad has wiped down twice. People: Mum, Dad, Aria, himself, Gran, Uncle Jack, Devon, and Mrs Adeyemi from next door. Eight. It's a good number. It's enough to make the room loud.
Mum comes down for dinner.
It is, in this house, an event, and no one treats it like one. Dad simply happens to be at the bottom of the stairs when she starts down, and Uncle Jack happens to be holding a blanket, and Aria happens to have cleared the armchair at the end of the table. Mum descends one step at a time, one hand on the rail, the other on Dad's forearm, wearing her good green jumper and a headscarf Aria tied for her that morning, bright gold, slightly crooked.
"Don't everyone stare," she says. "I'm not the Queen."
"You're better," says Uncle Jack. "The Queen never made me saltfish."
She laughs, and sits, and the room breathes out.
The table has been extended, covered with the red cloth that has a wine stain, hidden under the gravy boat. There are crackers, which Julian's Mum flinches at, then laughs at the cheap joke inside like everything is normal again, placing the too-big paper crown on Dad's head even though she won. Aria is wearing hers already, lopsided over her braids, the pink beads clicking whenever she turns.
Dad says grace. It is not long. It never is. He thanks God for the food, for the hands that made it, for the people at the table and the people who couldn't be. His voice catches on the latter part. Julian pretends not to hear.
"Amen," says the table.
Julian watches his mum's plate. A spoon of rice. A slice of turkey cut small. One roast potato, which she moves from one side to the other. She eats four forkfuls.
"So, Julian," Gran says, passing him the gravy. "How is that school treating you?"
"Good," he says. "Busy."
"Busy," Gran repeats. "And are they feeding you? And are they being decent to you? Those places can be funny with boys like you."
"Mum," Uncle Jack says.
"I'm only asking."
"They're fine," Julian says. "Everyone's been fine."
It is true. Nobody has said a single thing to him.
Devon pipes up across from Julian, fidgeting with his hands and trying to look like he isn't desperate for the presents. "Is it true you're up for Head Boy?"
Julian opens his mouth.
"He'll be Head Boy," his mother says, buttering a roll she is not going to eat, the way you'd say the post won't come, it's Sunday -- a simple, obvious case of cause and effect. The whole table turns towards her, and then towards him, glowing with pride, and Julian feels the word settle onto his shoulders like snow. He is not allowed to say if. Not with her sitting there, scarf slipping, every day of this year held in the way she looks at him: she has been telling the nurses at chemo, and the ladies at her support group, and the postman, and anyone who would listen. It is the one thing she has to hand out that is entirely good.
"We'll see," he says, and smiles.
"Modest," says Mrs Adeyemi approvingly. "That's how you know."
Aria pulls a cracker with him and wins the little plastic fortune-telling fish, which she places on her palm. It curls up. She declares this means she is passionate and fickle, and Mum laughs properly, and Julian holds on to the sound.
Presents are a modest affair, and everyone, bar Devon, agrees that is the best kind. Aria gets the keyboard she has been campaigning for since August. Dad gets slippers, and Mum gets a new dressing gown. Julian gets a jumper from Gran, a book token from Uncle Jack, an Arsenal keyring from Aria, and, from his parents, a thick, navy notebook with nothing written on the front.
"For next year," Mum says. "For all the plans."
The first page is not blank. In her handwriting sits a small phrase, rendered in biro: Julian. Whatever you decide, I will have been proud first. Mum x
He closes it before he can search out the signs of sickness in the handwriting.
"Thanks, Mum."
"You hate it."
"I love it."
"Good," she says.
Later, when the family begins arguing over the washing-up, and Gran is stuck entertaining Devon with his new Hot Wheels set, Julian takes the bin bags out. The back garden is small and dark, and the patio slabs are slick with a snow that never settled. Over the fence, next door's fairy lights blink in a long, tired loop, red and gold and red. His breath hangs in front of him. For the first time all day, it is quiet.
He does not hear the door, only the click of a lighter that doesn't catch, and then Uncle Jack beside him with his coat over his shoulders and an unlit cigarette between two fingers.
"Don't tell your mother," Jack says.
"I won't." Julian almost laughs. They stand side by side looking at the bins. Somewhere behind the rooftops, a car passes, tyres squeaking on the wet road. And under it, so faint he could be imagining it, there is the hum: the same note that lives in the chapel's lights at night, when the prefects have gone and the building lets out its breath, and for a second the cold in the garden is not the cold of December at all.
"Do you hear that?" he asks.
Jack tilts his head politely, though the answer is obvious. "Hear what?"
Julian listens. He hears nothing but a dog three gardens down, and the intro to Last Christmas radiating from next door, and the distant clatter of his sister loading the dishwasher wrong.
"Nothing," he says. "Sorry. Long day."
"It's Christmas. They're all long." Jack claps him once on the shoulder. "Come in before you freeze. Your gran's cutting the cake," he says, before slipping away.
Farah and Ahmed are in her room by ten past five, both small bodies clambered up onto the bed and sat on her legs, poking and prodding her like a corpse.
“She’s awake,” Ahmed whispers.
“Her eyes are closed.”
“That’s what awake people do when they’re pretending.”
“It’s five,” Hannah says into the pillow.
“It’s Christmas,” Ahmed says, before settling back onto his knees, pressing directly into Hannah's stomach. She tries not to wince as she turns her face away and sighs loudly into the duvet. At school she wakes to a bell and lies there in the dark until she feels like a person again. Here, two elbows land in her ribs and she is simply a sister. She can't quite decide which she prefers
By half past six the living room is a sea of wrapping paper, which her father chases behind uselessly with a bin-bag, because he cannot stand a mess, even on Christmas. Ahmed drives his new remote-controlled car straight into the tree, showering the carpet in small barbs of green plastic. Farah unwraps her 48 pack of new felt tips and announces that her notebook with a lock is not to be read by anyone but 'exspechally Ahmed', and Hannah sits there last, holding her small flat box, wrapped in fancy ribbon, waiting for the noise to die down before she opens it.
Eventually, she does. Inside is a thin silver chain with a plain cross, worn smooth at the edges. “It was my mother’s,” her mum says, already rising to cross the room. “She wore it all the way from Lahore. I had it cleaned.” She fastens the clasp, hands resting on her shoulders a moment longer than required. “Now you carry something of us.”
“I always carry you,” Hannah says, as a joke.
Her mother does not laugh. “Good. Keep doing that.”
The Christmas service at the centre is long, loud and joyful. The kids do the nativity, and Ahmed sings a five second solo about the sheep and the shepherds, off key and out of tune with a tea-towel on his head. Farah stumbles over her lines, and Hannah mouths them back to her from the audience, some kiddy babble about stars and His light. Her mother sings every verse with her eyes closed and one hand raised, as if she must be heard in Heaven, and Hannah finds herself joining in, easy as anything. Here is not St Anne's. No one is judging her tone, or accent, or waiting ti see if she forgets the words. Here, it is easy. The congregation welcomes her.
Then Pastor Daniel asks for a moment of silence.
She bows her head. The hall settles into the sound of a hundred people not speaking: a cough, a creaking chair, a baby fussing. Ten dozen heads all bowed in silence, all thinking of the same thing and different people: of Jesus ans his love, of their own children, and siblings, and sisters and brothers in a thousand different countries. Hannah's thoughts went straight to the prefect girl, and her voice, the way she sings in Mass and answers questions so eloquently you'd think she'd been the one asking, her tone so polished and perfect. And under it, there is a hum.
Her eyes open.
It is the chapel at dusk, the note in the walls of St Anne’s. It is here, in a hall that smells of coffee and tinsel, beneath a cardboard crib and glitteron the projector. She looks at the keyboard, switched off beneath its cloth. At the amplifier, its lead coiled on top, unplugged. At the strip lights, the ticking radiator.
Nothing explains it.
Pastor Daniel says “Amen,” the noise rushes back, and the hum is gone. Hannah’s hand has closed around the cross at her throat.
Lunch is crowded and happy and relentlessly full: aunties with dishes of their own, a cousin from Leicester with a baby, biryani beside roast chicken beside a trifle soaked in cardamom syrup. Hannah sits between her mother and Liza Auntie and eats everything put in front of her.
“And the school?” Liza Auntie asks. “And the girls?”
“They’re fine.”
“Fine,” Liza Auntie repeats, in the tone of a woman who has raised children. “You hear this, Aisha?”
“I hear it,” says her mother, and finds Hannah’s knee under the table with a single firm pat.
Her father stands to toast her. “Our scholar.” The table echoes it.
That night, with the guests gone and Farah and Ahmed carried to bed, Hannah kneels beside her own. The house is full of quiet sound, and for once, the night does not unsettle her: the boiler filling, her mother on the phone to Lahore, Urdu rising and falling through the wall.
Please help Mum not worry so much.
Please help me do well in exams.
Please keep Farah and Ahmed safe.
She stops. There is a fourth thing. She said it last time, and stopped, startled, and has carried it all week like a stone in her shoe. She does not say it. Instead she stays on her knees in the dark, eyes open, and does what Pastor Daniel asked. She stays quiet.
The hum comes back.
The house is too warm, and it smells of everything at once. Charlie lies on top of the duvet in their childhood bedroom, still dressed from the night before, listening to the kitchen through the floor, the clatter of the big roasting tin sparking behind their eyes like a fire-cracker. Their dad sings along to the radio in the wrong key, as he has every Christmas morning for as long as Charlie has been alive. It should be a comfort. They try to let it be one.
The room is exactly as they left it in September. The glow-in-the-dark stars on the ceiling have mostly lost their glow. The Frankenstein essay, marked and returned with a B-minus and where is YOUR argument? in red, is folded in the front pocket of their bag. Beneath the bed, a shoebox of old birthday cards. Everything is smaller than it was, as if the room has been quietly shrinking while they were away.
Their phone buzzes.
Alice: merry xmas u absolute disaster
Alice: my nan has given me a fish-shaped soap
Charlie: lucky
Charlie: i got a thermos
Alice: sexy
Alice: u ok?
Charlie: yeah. just tired. family stuff
Alice: ok. text me if not x
They put the phone face down on their chest.
"Charlie!" Their mum, up the stairs. "Come and help me with the sprouts!"
The kitchen is a heat wall. Charlie's mum stands at the counter in her Christmas apron plastered in cheap reindeer and snowflakes, a glass of fizz already sweating beside the chopping board.
"You've got your dad's jumper on," she says.
"It was on the radiator."
"It suits you. It's a bit big, though, isn't it?"
"It's meant to be big."
"Of course," she says, and turns back to the sprouts.
That's the thing about home. Nobody says anything. It's all small glances and careful sentences, and Charlie hates it. They peel the outer leaves off sprout after sprout and pretend not to notice that their mum has been hovering at their elbow for ten minutes, pretending to look for the colander.
By one o'clock there are eight at the table: Mum, Dad, Gran, Uncle Rob and his new girlfriend Priya, their cousin Tamsin, and her daughter, Ellie, and Charlie. Charlie takes the seat nearest the door. Plates start to travel hand to hand around the table, heavy, steaming, and Charlie's stomach clenches and hollows at the same time, like two people pulling on a cracker. It's just food, they tell themself. It's only Christmas dinner. They have told themself this in various forms since the beginning of December, standing in the lift at school, in the dining hall queue, in the dark of their dorm. It has never once helped.
"Go on, love," Gran says. "Get stuck in."
Charlie picks up their fork.
They eat a piece of turkey. They eat a potato, slowly. They eat three sprouts and then talk to Priya about her job at the hospital for such a sustained and enthusiastic length of time that they're almost proud of themself. Every so often they catch their mum's eyes on their plate and then away again, and the tiny pause in her chewing when she thinks they aren't looking.
Under the table, Charlie digs a thumbnail into the pad of their finger.
"Not hungry, darling?" Mum asks.
"Just pacing myself."
"Quite right," says Uncle Rob, who hasn't noticed anything, bless him. "It's a marathon, not a sprint."
The table laughs. Charlie laughs too, half a beat late, and for just a moment the rope goes slack and they're a person at a table, a person among people. They eat two more forkfuls without counting. Then they notice that they haven't counted, and the clench comes straight back. They put the fork down.
Pudding is lit with a flourish. Dad does the brandy and the lights go off, and for a moment the whole room is only blue flame and faces.
"Make a wish," Gran says, as if it's a birthday.
Charlie doesn't know what to wish. They stare into the little blue fire and don't wish anything at all.
"You've gone pale," their mum says quietly, leaning across. "Do you want some air?"
"I'm fine."
"You don't have to be."
"I'll just get some water," they say, and stand.
The downstairs loo is small and cold, and smells of lavender and bleach from Mum's obsessive cleaning 'for the guests'. Charlie runs the tap and holds their wrists under it, watching their own face in the mirror. The collarbones showing at the neck of their dad's jumper. It is not enough.
When they come back to the dining room, the table is half-cleared. Someone has saved them a bowl of pudding with a modest spoonful of custard, and their mum is pretending to be very interested in the dishwasher.
Sam sits in the back of the Land Rover, shivering, nose twitching at the stink of wet dog, with the rifle case across his knees.
“Wind’s from the west,” Angus, the head stalker, says. “We’ll go up by the burn.”
“Good man.” Dad speaks to the windscreen. “Sam. Try to listen to him.”
They climb for an hour, then crawl for another, on their stomachs through heather that soaks straight through Sam’s tweed. The sky is the colour of cotton wool. Below the ridge, a dozen hinds graze with their ears turning like small radar dishes, and Sam lies very still with the rifle’s cold wood against his cheek and feels, to his irritation, nothing at all. It is a clean feeling. He could get used to it.
“The one on the left,” Angus murmurs. “Behind the shoulder.”
The shot cracks off the hillside and comes back twice. The hind folds neatly, and the others are gone before it has finished falling.
Angus grunts. Dad says nothing for a long moment, then he lets out a breath through his nose and claps Sam once on the back, hard enough to hurt.
“Good,” he says. “That’s the first thing you’ve done properly since the summer.”
The summer. That is how it is said in this family, a season with a definite article, like a war.
By the time they reach it, steam is rising from the hind into the cold. Dad kneels, dips two fingers in the blood and draws them down Sam’s cheeks, one line each side. It is tradition. Rupert cried when it was his turn, and Dad has told the story at every Christmas since, proudly. Sam simply grins.
Dad’s hand stills on his face.
“Leave it on,” he says, after a moment. “Until dinner’s done.”
They sit down at seven, eight of them under the stags’ heads in a room that stinks of cold. Dad at one end and Mum at the other. Granny Bea on Dad’s right with her cane hooked on the chair, nobody’s fool. Aunt Tilly, Uncle Graham, Cousin Rupert, and Rupert’s girlfriend Arabella.
The venison is last week’s stag. It is dark and rich and tastes of the hill. Sam eats all of it.
“And how is the school?” Granny asks. “I’m told it’s very strict.”
“It’s doing him good,” Dad says.
“It’s lovely,” Mum says, in the same breath. “Isn’t it, darling? He’s made lots of friends.”
Sam’s cheeks have stiffened. He can feel the blood cracking when he smiles, and every time it does Granny’s eyes flick to it, and then to him.
“Hmm.” Granny cuts a potato precisely in half. “I should hope so.”
Rupert laughs into his wine.
"Sam, darling, pass the bread sauce to your Auntie,” Mum pipes up quickly, voice bright.
"Course." He does it with a flourish, and a wink for Aunt Tilly, who flaps a hand at him and says, "Oh, you're terrible," in a voice that means the opposite.
It's easy. It's always easy, with people who want to be charmed. He tells the story about the Economics teacher and the fire drill, leaving out the bit where he was hiding behind the sports shed with Edie at the time, and Uncle Graham laughs so hard he has to put his glass down.
"Seventeen and already a raconteur," Graham says. "He gets that from my side."
"He gets it from not paying attention,” says Dad, not looking up.
The table almost laughs, descending into a terse silence at Charles’ word. It’s Arabella who breaks it, with a social grace nobody ever taught her. She leans across the table, lovely and nervous and trying so hard. “Rupert said you’d had some trouble at your old school, Sam, and I just wanted to say—”
Nobody moves.
Rupert smiles into his glass. He’s been waiting all evening for someone else to say it.
A girl from the village in an ill-fitting waistcoat is at Dad’s elbow with the claret. “We don’t discuss that at the table,” Dad says, swirling his glass.
Her hand is shaking.
The wine goes over the rim of his glass in a dark, quick bloom across the white damask and onto the Georgian salt cellar.
“Oh God,” the girl whispers. “I’m so sorry, sir, I’m so–”
“Oh, it doesn’t matter, dear,” Mum says, too fast. “Truly, it’s only wine–”
Dad does not look up. He doesn’t look at the stain or at her. He moves his hand six inches to the left, out of the spreading red as the girl kneels and blots at the cloth with a napkin. Her hands are red and shaking and the wine is soaking through to the wood, and there is not one person at the table who looks at her except Sam, and he stares, at her, on her knees, with her chest squeezed into a too-small waistcoat, as if she hadn’t the mind to change into something appropriate for Christmas. This is paid work, and here she is, dressed like a whore. A job like this is worth investing in.
“Tell Mrs MacLeod,” Dad says to Mum, quite pleasantly, over the sound of her scrubbing, “not to send that one again.”
Granny finishes her thought as if the exchange never happened. “Butlers have always had their vices, Arabella. We simply used to have the sense to keep them in the family.”
“Oh,” says Arabella, “I didn’t mean—”
Mum drops a fork. She laughs at herself, too loudly, and Rupert laughs with her, and Dad carves another slice of venison with great attention. For a moment the candle flames seem very far away, as though Sam is looking at them from underneath glass. Then the grin comes back and the room returns. It is a good grin. He learned it here, in this chair, from watching how the people who love him make a thing disappear with nothing but language.
“Honestly, Arabella,” he says, “it was all terribly boring. A misunderstanding with a lawyer.”
When the port comes out and the talk turns to Boxing Day, Sam slips out.
The terrace is freezing. The stars are enormous, close and cold and indifferent. He doesn’t hear the door, only a match, and then Uncle Graham beside him in his dinner jacket with the end of a cigar glowing between two fingers. They stand looking at the dark where the hill is. Graham draws and exhales, and the smoke goes straight up.
“He isn’t angry, you know,” Graham says. “Angry he’d have shouted at you in September and been done with it.”
“What is he, then?”
“Frightened.” Graham turns the cigar. “The Hargreaves boy is out of hospital. His father rang again on Tuesday.”
Sam says nothing. He hasn’t thought about the boy since he started at St Anne’s. Jackson Hargreaves. It was a name on a court file, and at the bottom of it was a stamp saying ‘not guilty’. It was all Sam had to care about.
“The county’s version is very simple,” Graham says. “Nice boy, good family, a bit of cocaine at a house party, a bit more sold to his friends to pay for it. Half the men at that table have done worse and been given a seat on a board for it.” He looks at Sam sidelong. “It’s the other business he can’t stand.”
“What other business?”
“You know what.” Graham’s voice is gentle. “That boy from the shop. The Asian lad on the night till.”
It begins, for Sam, on the glen road in the summer after the referendum, with the heat lying thick on the heather and the whole county arguing about who counted as one of us. He bought his cigarettes at the Chaudhrys’ shop at the end of the road. Reena did the till in the evenings, revising for her Highers behind the counter with a highlighter in her teeth, and she was nice to him.
People in the village rarely were, to the families that lived up the hill, and she respected them.
The photograph was taken in the doorway of the shop at midnight. A figure in a hooded fleece, face turned away, with Sam’s arm around them. The fleece was her brother’s, with JASEEM CHAUDHRY stitched on the chest, because it was cold, and because Reena could never find her own.
Jas worked nights. He was nineteen, with a place at Dundee. After Hargreaves had collapsed on a lawn, the county badly needed an explanation for where the cocaine had come from that was not itself: he became the Asian boy from the shop that surely was a front, leading our young men astray. That July Dad had stood at the head of the table and toasted getting our country back, and two weeks later somebody put a brick through the Chaudhrys’ window with a note that read something to the tune of ‘Paki faggots!! Hands off our kids!!’.
Sam forgets the exact wording.
“I’m not asking whether the rumour’s true,” Graham says. “If it’s a boy, it’s a boy, and that’s that.”
That’s that.
The words land like a slap of cold water. It is not relief. He knows relief, and this is the opposite.
Easy for him. Graham with his cigar and his good manners and his sister’s money, who was never born into this and has never had to carry it. Soft. They’re all soft, the ones like that, they're the ones that are alright with making life worse for the rest of us.
“It wasn’t a boy,” he says.
Graham waits.
“There wasn’t a boy. It was his sister. Reena.” The name comes out in a rush. “She was in his fleece.” For some stupid, childish moment, he wants to say ‘and her hair was soft, she was nice to me, she was pretty’. He feels like a fool. Like Romeo throwing himself at Benvolio's feet in boyish folly, a moment of idiotic weakness in the gardens over that month’s particular Rosaline.
He steels himself. He is not a fairy. She was not his Juliet.
“Your father would rather have a gay son than a shopgirl for a daughter-in-law,” Graham says at last, very quietly. “A boy is a phase. A boy can be sent away and sorted out. Do you know what a girl is?”
“Yes,” Sam says. You’re my mother’s brother. She was not born into this and neither were you. A woman is a leech. A brown one is a parasite. “I know.”
Graham puts a hand on his shoulder. “Go to bed, Sam. Wash that off first. You’ve done your duty.”
He stands at the taps, and runs cold water over his hands until they numb. His cheeks crack, skin tightened with blood, and he raises his wet fingers to the stain. Then he remembers Graham, and all his soft, snowflake drivel, the hand on his shoulder: “That’s that. Wash that off first.” He is not a Butler. He knows nothing of our struggle. He does not lay claim to this land.
Samuel Lachlan dried his hands. The boy in the mirror grinned back through cracked, bloodied cheeks, eyes crusted in red.
Leeches, all of them.
The arrivals hall at Pudong has been decorated for a holiday that most of the people in it are not celebrating. Tinsel is looped around the pillars, and a giant inflatable Santa, slightly deflated, leans over the taxi sign. Somewhere a recording of “Jingle Bells” is playing in a key it was never written in. Jinlian has been awake for twenty-three hours. A cancelled flight at Heathrow cost her two nights and a bed made of three plastic chairs, and she lands on Christmas morning at ten past six with her suitcase wheel clicking, her phone at nine percent and her plait coming loose.
The phone buzzes. Mama has sent a voice message.
“Jinlian, Liu shifu is stuck on the expressway, there has been an accident, he says an hour. Don’t wait. Take a taxi from the official queue, not anyone who approaches you. I’ll pay on the app. Send me the plate number before you get in.”
The queue is long. A marshal in a yellow vest is working his way down it with a bored cough, and he waves her to the third cab. She photographs the plate and sends it. The driver is in his fifties, with a card on the dashboard that says ZHOU.
“Wukang Road,” she says.
“French Concession,” he says, as though this is a small joke between them. “Long way. England?” He has seen the luggage tag. “Cold there?”
“Wet.”
“Ha. Like here.” He coughs again, wetly, into his fist. She notices that he has been awake for longer than she has.
“Do you have to work today?”
“Every day is a work day, miss.”
“Xinku le,” she says, quietly. Thank you for your trouble, as one says to anyone who has been working hard for you. In the mirror his eyes look surprised. For a moment she thinks he will say something, but he only nods, and turns the heating up a notch.
Outside, the city comes on in layers. The expressway, the flat grey fields of the airport’s edge, the towers of Lujiazui floating in haze, the Pearl Tower pink above it. Under a flyover she sees heaps of shared bikes, orange and yellow, tangled together like sleeping animals. She can read every sign. At St Anne’s she is always translating, and here the translating has stopped, and she doesn’t know what to do with the quiet in her head.
When she gets out on Wukang Road, she tips him twenty on a fare of twelve. He protests. She says, “Merry Christmas,” in English, and then, more confident this time, Shengdan kuaile.
The plane trees along the road are bare, their bark peeling in grey and cream patches. The building is one of those old French-built blocks from 1934, with a curved front, a brass-gated lift and a doorman called Lao Chen who has known her since she was four. He takes her suitcase and calls her xiaojie.
“Your granddaughter’s exams,” she says. “Did she pass the piano one?”
His whole face changes. “Grade eight. Merit.”
“Tell her congratulations from me.”
On the fourth floor the door opens before she knocks. Mama is in an apron over her wool dress, flour on her hands, and she looks at Jinlian for a long moment, and then folds her in. She smells of dough and Chanel, and under it something that has always been just home.
“You came on your own.”
“I’m not a child, Mama.”
“No.” Mama holds her at arm’s length and checks her over, quickly. Her gaze snags on the shadows under Jinlian’s eyes. “Sleep for an hour. I’ll wake you at ten for church.”
In her old room, with its ceiling and its small brown stain, she lies down in her coat and listens. Then there is a knock, and the door opens.
“Welcome home, Xiao Lian,” Baba says.
She is crying before she can stop herself, silently, into the pillow. He doesn’t ask why. He just sits on the edge of the bed in his shirtsleeves, with his cold hand on her hair, and says, “Your mother told me not to wake you,” and doesn’t leave.
The church is an old brick building near People’s Square, and it is full. It is always full at Christmas: the regulars in their good coats, and the curious, who have come for the carols and stand in the aisles holding their phones. Ushers with red armbands move along the walls. Mama has braided her hair, in her dark green wool, sleeves to the wrist. Waipo sits on her other side in the family pew, in the same padded jacket she has worn for twenty years, with a small black hymnbook held in both hands. When the organ begins, Jinlian knows it before the first line. Ping’an ye. Silent night, in Chinese, is peaceful night: the same two characters as the stickers on Mama’s apples. For seven weeks she has been singing this in English, watching the other girls’ mouths. Here she doesn’t have to watch anyone. She sings with her whole voice.
On the last verse the organist holds the final chord, and the whole church holds its breath with it. Waipo’s hand closes around hers. Under the chord, below the pipes and the held voices, there is another note. Low, steady, patient. When the organ releases, it stays a breath longer. Waipo doesn’t look at her. Her hand is very tight.
At one o’clock they sit down. Mama and Baba, Waipo, Jinlian, Pastor Zhao and his wife, and Mr and Mrs Liu, Baba’s oldest business partner and his wife.
“Our Weiwei,” Mr Liu is saying, “has just finished his first term at Imperial. They say it is very demanding. He rings us every Sunday, without fail.”
Everyone laughs where they ought to. Jinlian laughs a second late, in Mandarin, which has never happened to her before.
“And you, Jinlian?” Mrs Liu says. “The English girls. Are they kind to you?”
Mama’s gaze sharpens. Jinlian considers it. She could give the answer Mrs Liu is hoping for. She could give the true one. And then she sees Mrs Liu’s hands, turning a ring round and round her finger beneath the table, and understands that this question is not really about her.
“Some of them are very kind,” she says. “The post is terrible, though. At school, we don’t get letters for weeks. I’m sure Weiwei is only busy.”
Mrs Liu’s eyes fill. She dips her head to her soup. “Yes,” she says. “Yes. I’m sure.”
Zhang Ayi comes round with the fish, and Baba looks up and says, “Thank you, Zhang Ayi. How is Dongdong’s exam?”
After lunch, she finds Waipo alone on the balcony, in a thin patch of winter sun, drinking hot water from a jam jar. The plane trees below are black against the grey. The small black hymnbook is open on the iron railing.
“My mother hid this under the kitchen floor in 1967,” Waipo says, without turning round. “The Red Guards took the Bible. They didn’t think to look under the rice jar.”
Jinlian looks at the flyleaf. It has an English inscription in faded brown ink: Presented to Li Wenhui by Miss Edith Hartley, Shanghai, 1931. The handwriting is a stranger’s, upright and careful. She thinks, for no reason she can name, of the brass plaques in St Anne’s library.
“Her teachers were American missionaries,” Waipo says. “They gave her English, and hymns, and a God. My mother kept two of the three.”
“Waipo--”
“In church, you went away.”
“No.”
“Mm.” Waipo doesn’t argue.“The Bible says to test the spirits. If something speaks to you in the dark, ask it in whose name it comes. If it will not say, it is not of God.”
“And if it doesn’t answer?”
“Then you know.”
That night her phone buzzes against the pillow.
Isla: merry xmas!! mum made me watch the queen’s speech. save me
Jinlian: merry christmas. we went to church, then lunch.
Isla: so basically the same as here
Jinlian: yes. but the food is better
Isla: rude :/
Mama knocks, and sits at the end of the bed with Jinlian’s feet in her lap through the duvet.
“If you do not want to go back after New Year,” she says, “you can say so.”
Jinlian opens her mouth to say it’s fine. What comes out instead is, “I want to go back.”
It surprises her more than it surprises Mama.
“Good,” Mama says, and presses her lips to the top of her head, and begins to pray, very quietly, in the dark, as she has every night of Jinlian’s life. When she has finished she leaves the door open a hand’s width.
Alone, Jinlian lies in the cold and listens. The note is there, a half-tone under the sound of the city.
Ask it in whose name it comes.
She feels foolish, and does it anyway. She whispers, in Mandarin, to the dark: “In whose name?”
The note does not answer.